As a culinary journalist with a penchant for discovering SoHo’s unique dining gems, it’s hard to overlook Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer. If you’re hunting for the best milkshakes in NYC, specifically the ones that not only taste incredible but also look like an Instagram dream, Black Tap’s iconic CrazyShakes® will be your perfect stop.
The Craze Behind CrazyShakes®
The milkshakes at Black Tap are more than just dessert—they’re a spectacle. These over-the-top creations, known as CrazyShakes®, have become a phenomenon across social media, drawing both locals and tourists alike. Black Tap’s SoHo location is especially popular, where the lineup of colorful, larger-than-life shakes often leaves customers waiting eagerly for a chance to indulge.
But what makes these shakes so special? Each CrazyShake® is not only massive in size but also loaded with a variety of sweet toppings—think whole slices of cake, lollipops, and cookies balancing on a thick, creamy base. One of the most popular choices is the Cakeshake®, a cake batter shake rimmed with rainbow sprinkles and topped with a slice of Funfetti cake, whipped cream, and a cherry. If chocolate is more your thing, the Brooklyn Blackout packs a serious punch with a chocolate frosted rim, mini brownies, and even more chocolate goodness.
For those who prefer fruity flavors, the Cotton Candy Shake stands out with its vanilla base, adorned with pink and blue rock candy, a giant lollipop, and a cloud of cotton candy. It’s the kind of shake that takes you back to childhood carnival memories.
Not Just CrazyShakes: The Classics and Vegan Options
While the CrazyShakes® are undoubtedly the headliners, Black Tap doesn’t forget about traditionalists. The classic shakes menu includes tried-and-true flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry, but with the same high-quality ingredients and attention to detail that makes everything at Black Tap stand out.
What’s more, Black Tap is committed to inclusivity. Vegan customers aren’t left out of the milkshake fun—most CrazyShakes® can be made with vegan ice cream and whipped cream without sacrificing the flavor or indulgence. Whether you’re dairy-free or simply trying to eat plant-based, Black Tap has you covered with equally extravagant vegan shake options.
Pair Your Shake with a Burger (or Two)
Black Tap’s reputation as a burger joint is equally well-earned. If you’re in SoHo, you’re not just coming for the shakes; you’re here for a full dining experience. Their burgers, like the All-American or the Tennessee Burger, pair perfectly with a shake and complete the meal. Black Tap’s menu emphasizes quality ingredients, using prime beef and creative toppings like Jack Daniel’s-infused sauces and crispy bacon.
The shakes also complement a variety of other comfort food items on the menu. From fried pickles to Korean BBQ wings, these savory delights serve as the ideal contrast to your sweet and indulgent milkshake.
The Experience: SoHo’s Vibrant Dining Scene
Beyond the food, part of Black Tap’s allure is the vibe. The SoHo location is a throwback to the 80s and 90s with its street-art-covered walls and old-school hip-hop soundtrack. It’s an energetic yet laid-back spot that attracts everyone from families to Instagram influencers. The combination of delicious food and a unique atmosphere makes Black Tap more than just a meal—it’s a full-on event.
Black Tap’s SoHo location is also a prime spot for those wanting to explore the neighborhood. Whether you’re strolling through SoHo’s iconic art galleries or heading to nearby Little Italy or Nolita, it’s easy to pop into Black Tap for a shake before or after exploring the area.
Why Black Tap Stands Out in NYC’s Competitive Milkshake Scene
New York City is filled with amazing milkshake options, but Black Tap sets itself apart by going bigger, bolder, and crazier. While other shops may focus on flavor alone, Black Tap marries flavor with presentation. Their CrazyShakes® are almost too beautiful to eat—and definitely too hard to resist snapping a photo.
Morgenstern’s Finest Ice Cream in the West Village, for example, offers shakes with unique, palate-driven flavors like Yuzu Poppyseed, but Black Tap’s emphasis on sheer indulgence is unmatched. Similarly, while places like Davey’s Ice Cream deliver comfort with a pie-blended milkshake, Black Tap continues to push boundaries with towering, inventive creations.
For locals and tourists alike, Black Tap SoHo has become a destination for anyone looking to experience the absolute best milkshakes in NYC. Their CrazyShakes® are not just food, but works of art that manage to strike a perfect balance between classic American indulgence and modern, Instagram-worthy flair.